Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Prompt #6--The Glass of Water


I would say that Bolingbroke has the most time onstage, and his aspirations seem to be much higher and nobler than anyone else’s.  While the audience can undoubtedly respect Anne’s desires to be a free queen and Abigail and Masham’s desires to wed, I believe that Bolingbroke’s complicated plot to shut down the Duchess’ needless and destructive war is the most important thread of the story.  Unfortunately, it is also pretty difficult to follow—it was always very easy for me to see where any of the lovers were coming from, even the Duchess.  However, I still don’t really understand the intricacies of Bolingbroke’s plot, and I’m sure I didn’t while I was reading the play.  Of course, the audience would note that Bolingbroke is scheming throughout the entire play and that he always seems to be a few steps ahead of the Duchess, so even if he cannot be played as a true protagonist, he would probably at least look like the scheming mastermind—and, let’s face it, in a well-made play, the character who plots and gossips the most is the most important character.

Ultimately, though, I can see how it wouldn’t be too productive to think of this play in terms of a singular protagonist.  After all, the audience certainly doesn’t see anything from one character’s perspective.  While there is one distinct villain to dislike, the rest of the cast is almost an ensemble, and forcing Bolingbroke to be the main character is a bit of an unnecessary stretch.  After all, this is a play about the relationships and secrets shared by many people, not about one person, specifically.

4 comments:

  1. I know how you feel because when reading, I also lost track of what Bolingbroke’s real motives were at times. That being said, I do believe that he’s slightly more important than everyone else because he is the man running the show (so if I had to pick a single protagonist it’d be him). I hate to assume, but in your post you state that there is one distinct villain in the piece; I’m assuming it’s the Duchess. The Duchess is a roadblock in terms of progress throughout the play, but she’s not a villain per say. She’s not cut-and-dry bad, but the way the play is written, it almost seems like Scribe forces the reader to put a negative label on her. Pending on one’s point of view, I believe an argument can be made for the Duchess as the protagonist as well as the Queen, Abigail and Marsham. However a protagonist is not necessary for this play in particular because as you said,"...this is a play about the relationships and secrets shared by many people, not about one person, specifically."

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your point about how Bolingbrook's story line is very hard to follow. I always thought Masham and Abigail were the protagonist, but their story line is extremely easy to follow! Their dialogue was very repetitive and easy to understand. Therefore, I am second-guessing my opinion! I feel like Scribe would not have created such a complex plot for Bolingbrooke if he was not the protagonist. This post definitely made me wonder and re-examine my ideas!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I see why you think that Bolingbroke's storyline is the most important. However, I disagree. I definitely agree that he is the one pulling the strings and is always "a few steps ahead of the duchess", but I don't think that' sufficient enough to make his story the focal point. I think it, more so, justifies him to be a protagonist. I agree that there really isn't one particular protagonist because a few members of the "ensemble" equally have points in the script where we follow their story, and hope they get what they want.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Chassity in that Bolinbroke is not always ahead of the Duchess. Until Masham murdered his cousin, then Bolinbroke would have had a difficult time manipulating his standing at court and with the Queen because he would have been too tied down working with his large debt. The Duchess could have easily held that over his head and put him in jail (or whatever method of preventing Bolinbroke's approaching the Queen and winning her over to his side). However, I do agree with you that Bolinbroke seems to take the place of the central character. Many of the decisions and schemes he comes up with further the plot so that we end up getting the full story, despite the fact that it can be hard to follow at times.

    ReplyDelete